Starter discussions

Should local communities be able to veto refugee accommodation? Local input matters, but a complete veto can obstruct a broader humanitarian responsibility.

Should international courts be allowed to prosecute leaders without national consent? Universal accountability can conflict with sovereignty and concerns about selective enforcement.

Should government contracts favor domestic firms even at a higher price? Domestic capacity and jobs compete with value for taxpayers and access to specialized suppliers.

Should politicians be paid the national median wage? Pay alignment signals solidarity but may make public office easier for independently wealthy candidates.

Should wealthy citizens pay an exit tax when they move abroad? An exit tax may protect a shared tax base while restricting mobility and investment choices.

Should public services be denied to people who refuse to pay taxes? Reciprocity matters, but denying essentials can deepen harm and involve complicated disputes over responsibility.

Should governments cap the size of inherited fortunes? Limits could reduce entrenched advantage while restricting how families transfer lawfully acquired property.

Should public money rescue banks whose executives took reckless risks? Protecting depositors and the economy can clash with making decision-makers bear the consequences.

Should governments ration personal carbon use instead of relying on prices? Equal allowances may seem fair while restricting choices that vary with geography and family needs.

Should wealthy countries pay poorer countries to preserve forests? Shared environmental benefits support payment, but arrangements can complicate sovereignty and local livelihoods.

Should economic sanctions be rejected when civilians bear the largest costs? Pressure on leaders can spill onto people who have little control over their government's actions.

Should countries stop exporting weapons to governments accused of abuses? Restrictions may uphold principles while reducing diplomatic influence or affecting defensive partnerships.