Robin

Should losing candidates pay for election challenges rejected as frivolous? Baseless challenges should have a financial cost rather than becoming a fundraising strategy.

Should autonomous weapons always require a human to approve each strike? Machines should not independently decide to kill people.

Should a manager earn more than the highest-paid specialist on their team? Responsibility for people and outcomes can justify a higher salary.

Can a society be fair without agreeing on what fairness means? Different principles may coexist, but institutions still have to resolve concrete conflicts between them.

Should people be socially punished for refusing to join a boycott? Collective action depends on participation, yet coercion can obscure genuine disagreement and personal constraints.

Should a proposal be public if the couple has not discussed marriage? A memorable gesture can create pressure when an honest answer becomes a public performance.

Can nationalism be morally defensible without treating outsiders as less important? Shared membership can justify commitments while stopping short of denying equal human worth.

Should billionaires receive honorary degrees because they donate money? Philanthropy can support education without necessarily constituting the intellectual achievement an honor implies… See more

Should friends always defend one another in public? Loyalty need not require endorsing conduct that deserves criticism or harms someone else.

Are people responsible for harms created by products they buy? Consumer choices matter, but information and practical alternatives are often limited.

Should being child-free become as publicly celebrated as parenthood? Recognition can reduce stigma without implying that different life choices must receive identical rituals.

Should schools contact parents about every change in a teenager's identity? Family involvement can support wellbeing while particular circumstances may require careful attention to priv… See more